October 9, 2012 | 2:21 PM |
Fresh Air: Existential Emptiness At The End Of Life
Listen to Fresh Air today for an insiders view of death and dying from a former critical care nurse who now counsels terminally ill people at the end of their lives. Some of those patients choose to die with an overdose of medications, which is legal in Oregon, Washington and Montana. Massachusetts voters will decide whether to legalize physician-assisted suicide in November.
Judith Schwartz, east coast regional coordinator for the nonprofit Compassion and Choices, tells Terry Gross that the top reason terminally ill patients say they want help dying is not because they’re in excruciating pain. She said people want to die when they can no longer do any of the large and small things they love. For some people that doesn’t matter, she said, but for the people it matters to, it matters a lot, and those patients stare straight into the “existential meaningless” of life.
Other topics in the broad-ranging interview include why inexperienced nurses in hospitals sometimes put terminally ill patients on suicide watch and how people sometimes change their hard fought plans at the very end.
“There are many people for whom death is not the worst thing that could happen to them,” Schwartz said. While others feel differently.
She tells the story of a dying man who, in a discussion about whether to stop eating and drinking, asked whether he would also have to give up his Scotch. “That,” Schwartz said, “should be the last to go.”
About the author
Blogger, CommonHealth Rachel Zimmerman worked as a staff reporter for The Wall Street Journal for 10 years, most recently covering health and medicine out of the paper’s Boston bureau. Rachel has also written for The New York Times, the (now-defunct) Seattle Post-Intelligencer and the alternative newspaper Willamette Week, in Portland, Ore., among other publications. Rachel co-wrote a book about birth, published by Bantam/Random House, and spent 2008 as a Knight Science Journalism Fellow at MIT. Rachel lives in Cambridge with her husband and two daughters. View all posts by Rachel Zimmerman →
MORE POSTS ABOUT
- Medicine/Science
- Personal Health
- death
- physician-assisted suicide
- practicing medicine
-
Mass. Blocks Higher Insurance Charges For Most Smokers
You’ve heard all the campaigns and statistics: Smoking Kills. It’s the leading cause of preventable death in the U.S. And, it’s expensive. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says smoking costs the country $193 billion a year in lost … Read More
- Advocate: Take 'Times' Coverage Of Sodium Report With Grain Of Salt
- Health Of The Nation: Obesity Up, But 'Notable' Decline In Physical Inactivity
-
Mass. Blocks Higher Insurance Charges For Most Smokers
You’ve heard all the campaigns and statistics: Smoking Kills. It’s the leading cause of preventable death in the U.S. And, it’s expensive. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says smoking costs the country $193 billion a year in lost … Read More
- Advocate: Take 'Times' Coverage Of Sodium Report With Grain Of Salt
- Health Of The Nation: Obesity Up, But 'Notable' Decline In Physical Inactivity
-
Paying Tribute To A Doctor's Invaluable Teacher: A Dead Body
For many doctors, the most important person on their journey from pre-med to licensed healer is dead. “When you start medical school, you begin to learn the details of cells and tissues and development and disease,” said Jared Wortzman, president … Read More
- End-Of-Life Conversation: From Kitchen Table To Your Doctor's Office
- Patrick, Citing Personal Experience, Voted Yes On Doctor-Assisted Suicide
-
Patrick, Citing Personal Experience, Voted Yes On Doctor-Assisted Suicide
For the record, Gov. Deval Patrick said his decision to vote in favor of physician assisted suicide was motivated largely by his experience with his mother near the end of her life, The Associated Press reports. The measure was defeated … Read More
- 'Ethically, Is This Right For Doctors To Do?' Help A Terminal Patient Die?
- Reader Connects Health Rationing Argument To 'Death With Dignity'
-
Paying Tribute To A Doctor's Invaluable Teacher: A Dead Body
For many doctors, the most important person on their journey from pre-med to licensed healer is dead. “When you start medical school, you begin to learn the details of cells and tissues and development and disease,” said Jared Wortzman, president … Read More
- Mass. Physicians Raise Concerns About Final Medical Marijuana Rules
- For Pre-Meds, Marathon Bombing Catalyzes Drive To Practice Medicine


