Longtime Mass. Planned Parenthood Leader Stepping Down

Dianne Luby, longtime head of the Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts

This just in from the Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts: Dianne Luby, who has led the league for 13 years, has told the board that she’ll step down at the end of this year.

(My first thought: “Wow, 13 years is a long time to endure the level of controversy that swirls around a group like Planned Parenthood, with all its work on contraception and abortion.”)

The Planned Parenthood press release says that Ms. Luby worked to “change the public conversations around sexual health,” to introduce a new approach to sex ed, and to expand access to sexual health care, particularly in “underserved communities.”
From the press release:

“Thirteen years ago, my overarching vision was to make PPLM an essential part of the mainstream healthcare community and I am so pleased about how far we’ve come,” said Ms. Luby. “I feel that this is an excellent time for me to be moving on. Not only are we successfully completing our five-year strategic plan, we have also reached our $30 million Sexual Health Matters campaign goal, which funded a broad range of health care initiatives.”

Under Dianne’s leadership, some of PPLM’s most notable accomplishments include:

•Opening five new health centers in Springfield, Fitchburg, Marlborough, Milford, and Somerville and building a new, eco-friendly facility in Worcester.
•Broadening public understanding of the full scope of PPLM’s programs and services by introducing its “Sexual Health Matters” brand.
•Developing a comprehensive sexuality education curriculum for middle schools and high schools that is now in 131 schools and reaching over 30,000 students. Wellesley Centers for Women is conducting a rigorous five-year evaluation of the middle school program’s effectiveness with very positive early results. Continue reading

Politico: From Death Panels to Birth Panels, Bachmann Weighs In

Michelle Bachman speaking (markn3tel/flickr)

Didn’t Michelle Bachmann exit the GOP race for president already?

No matter, here she is, reports Politico, not so subtly suggesting that the Obama administration’s birth control coverage policy for women might lead inexorably to a government-mandated childbirth policy. Wow.

The Minnesota congresswoman said the Obama administration’s contraception coverage mandate could be a slippery slope to a point where a “health dictator” decrees that women could only have one or two children. Continue reading

Considering The Vasectomy


Who knew a vasectomy could make such a great read? But here it is, in GQ, a gripping, hilarious, heart-breakingly honest account of one guy’s decision to take charge of family planning by knife.

As he awaits the surgeon, author Benjamin Percy notices the “walls are busy with gruesome anatomical diagrams, cross sections that make the male genitalia resemble charcuterie.” Then the action begins: “They go to work, flopping back my penis, arranging tools on a tray, positioning a stool between my legs. I squint into the blinding lights while the nurse snaps on latex gloves and my doctor shaves my scrotum. Then it’s time.”

Percy takes us through his decision to get a “v-sec,” noting that he loves, loves, loves his two children. “But a third?” he writes. “Outnumbered, we would have to switch from man-on-man to zone defense, and I can’t help but shudder when I imagine a red-faced baby wailing through the night, the bank statements withering further, the walls crayoned, and the laundry hampers reeking of spit-up and poo. An unexpected pregnancy, in other words, would be a nightmare.”

So he takes the plunge and makes a date with the surgeon:

I don’t scream, but I clamp my jaw so tightly it clicks. I arch my back so much I end up looking behind me at the door. The technique differs from doctor to doctor. Some cut diagonally. Some puncture “keyholes” with a hemostat on either side of the scrotum. Mine scalpels a vertical slash right down the middle. The room is cold, but I am sweating. How I regret not accepting the Valium. The doctor explains the procedure as it progresses. Apparently some men don’t have pronounced enough vas deferens, the tubes that carry sperm outward from the testicles, making the vasectomy impossible. But mine look great, he says. I would tell him thank you if I had a voice.

He will now sever the right vas deferens and excise a length of the tube, making recanalization close to impossible. “Now,” he says, his voice lowering, “you may feel a hot nauseating spike of pain that reaches up your right side.” Nobody I have spoken to, nothing I have read, mentioned anything about hot nauseating spikes of pain. Before I can steel myself to the idea, I hear a snip. The noise of garden shears deadheading geraniums.

I am unable to breathe. I cannot see what the doctor is doing, but he very well might have shoved a furnace-baked length of rebar through my groin and into my torso. I am introduced to vast, intricate networks of pain I never knew existed. Continue reading

Blunt Amendment Dead In Senate, Political Jockeying Alive And Well

(Mark Sardella/flickr)

The so-called Blunt amendment, which would have allowed employers to opt out of health care coverage they found objectionable — i.e., birth control for women — was voted down in the Senate 51-48, The New York Times reports.

But U.S. Sen. Scott Brown’s support for the amendment has become grist for the political mill, with flying press releases, outraged advocates and chest-thumping about religious freedom and morality all around. Here’s a sample of reaction we’ve received:

Planned Parenthood reacted swiftly with this:

Planned Parenthood League of Massachusetts (PPLM) expressed disappointment over Senator Scott Brown’s vote today for the overreaching Blunt Amendment that seeks to deny individuals access to essential health care. This measure would allow any employer or health plan to deny any health care service they find objectionable. It takes refusal for basic health care well beyond birth control – an employer could deny access to in-vitro fertilization, HIV/AIDS treatment, and other essential health care services.

“The reality is that the Blunt Amendment undermines fundamental tenets of the Affordable Care Act and the integrity of our nation’s health care system,” said Dianne Luby, President/CEO of PPLM. “We’re very disappointed that Senator Brown supported this attack on basic health care access. Then again, he did campaign in 2010 on promises to be the critical vote to defeat health care reform.”

Scott Brown’s office released this:

U.S. Senator Scott Brown (R-MA) issued the following statement after voting for the Blunt Amendment to protect religious freedom and allow a conscience exemption in health care for people of faith: Continue reading

NPR: Why Catholics Say ‘No’ To Contraception, But ‘Yes’ To Viagra

NPR’s Julie Rovner asks an excellent question in her report today about the ongoing uproar over new federal rules that would require employers to cover contraception as part of an overall package of preventative care for women. She writes:

If health insurance plans offered by Catholic-sponsored entities refuse to cover contraceptives for women because of the religion’s moral teachings banning artificial birth control, do they cover Viagra for men?

She says she got several emails asking just that after her story on the Obama administration’s change in the initial rule mandating coverage of birth control. (As part of the change, Obama said that hospitals, universities and charities sponsored by religious groups could opt out of covering contraception if their insurance companies did offer it to employees.) Continue reading

Dems: Romney Did Not Fight Contraception Mandate In Mass.

Breaking News Update: The New York Times reports: “Obama Administration Plans to Offer ‘Accommodation’ on Birth Control Rule, Officials Say.”

Leading Democrats in Massachusetts are pointing to contraception as the latest example of a flip flop from former Governor Mitt Romney.

Contraception, with an exemption for churches, became a required benefit in Massachusetts in 2002, the year before Mitt Romney was sworn in as governor. Phil Johnston, who held top state health care and Democratic party positions, says Mitt Romney never tried to repeal the mandate.  “He never mentioned that it would infringe upon religious freedoms and during the four years that Governor Romney served, he was totally silent on that issue.”

Romney aides say his original health coverage bill proposed eliminating all insurance mandates for individuals and small businesses covered through what would become the Health Connector. Since most large businesses are self-insured, and thus not subject to state mandates, these aides say Romney planned to remove mandates for most residents.

Former Health Care for All director John McDonough echoes Johnston’s recollection that Governor Romney never singled out contraception as an objectionable mandate. “The poster child for bad mandates,” remembers McDonough, “was in vitro fertilization, because it is so expensive.” Continue reading

Cardinal O’Malley: Either Violate Our Consciences Or Drop Health Coverage

It appears that Cardinal Sean O’Malley, the Archbishop of Boston, is gearing up for a fight.

Responding to the federal government’s recent ruling that most health insurance plans, even those provided to employees of Catholic hospitals, colleges and charities, must cover free contraceptives for women, O’Malley lashed out at the ruling calling it “an alarming and serious matter” that “strikes at the fundamental right to religious liberty for all citizens of any faith.”

In a letter dated January 2012 posted on his blog, O’Malley adds that “the federal government, which claims to be by, and for the people has just dealt a heavy blow to almost a quarter of those people — the Catholic population — and to the millions more who are served by the Catholic faithful.”

Then he issues this call to action:

…unless the rule is overturned, we Catholics will be compelled and must be prepared either to violate our consciences, or to drop health coverage for our employees Continue reading

Commentary: Beyond Komen, Planned Parenthood Remains Under Attack

Despite the breathtaking turnaround by the Komen foundation today on funding for Planned Parenthood, the organization remains under attack, according to Judy Norsigian, co-founder and executive director of Our Bodies Ourselves, and Ellen Shaffer, co-director of the Trust Women/Silver Ribbon Campaign, a project of the Center for Policy Analysis. In a blistering blog post today, they describe another assault on Planned Parenthood, this one by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops:

What Komen, and the evangelicals, and Republican Rep. Cliff Stearns, who launched the pointless political inquiry, and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops are really mad at Planned Parenthood about is this:

Part of what they do is help people plan. Parenthood. You know. They support birth control. In some cases, they provide it. Like your corner drugstore, but better.

And this week, the bishops are howling about it because the Obama administration refused to grant a broad religious exemption to contraception coverage. Continue reading

Plan B: Pharmacies Say ‘No’ To Teen Girls Even When Law Says Yes

Bad news for all the people who were upset at the Obama administration’s decision earlier this month requiring that teenage girls have a prescription to get the “Plan B” emergency contraceptive:

New research suggests that the broader context for that decision is even more troubling than previously known. It finds that many pharmacy staffers are blocking teen girls’ access to the “morning-after” pill even when the teenagers have a legal right to it. And those barriers are particularly bad in poor neighborhoods, where unintended pregnancies are especially common.

Lead researcher Dr. Tracey Wilkinson

“There’s a lot of misinformation and misunderstanding regarding this medication, and that’s universal,” said Dr. Tracey Wilkinson, a general pediatrics fellow at Boston Medical Center and lead author of a research letter just out online in the Journal of the American Medical Association. “We have a really efficacious form of pregnancy prevention that might not be accessible because of misinformation that’s out there.”

The Dec. 7 Obama administration decision concerned over-the-counter access to Plan B for girls under 17, but the research by Dr. Wilkinson’s team found that even for young women 17 and up, and even for teen girls who have a prescription, getting hold of emergency contraception can be a problem. The administration’s decision was disappointing, she said, but the study found that “even the way things stand is not working.”

The researchers called 943 pharmacies in five different cities — Nashville; Philadelphia; Cleveland; Austin, Texas; and Portland, Oregon — in late 2010, a solid year after the FDA had lowered the age of permission for over-the-counter access to 17. (Younger girls can also obtain emergency contraception but need a prescription.) Continue reading

CDC: 8 In 10 Teen Boys Use Condoms When Losing Virginity

I know they say that the brain’s planning areas tend to develop particularly late in teen boys, but the latest figures from the CDC on condom use are highly heartening: The number of teen boys who used condoms “at first sex” rose 9 percentage points between 2002 and 2010.

Clearly, when it matters, they’re planning ahead.

The full release from the CDC is below — including the latest snapshot of teen sex nationwide — and the full study is here.

More teen males using condoms

The percentage of teen males aged 15-19 years in the United States who used a condom the first time they had sex increased between 2002 and 2006-2010, according to a report from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

The report, “Teenagers in the United States: Sexual Activity, Contraceptive Use, and Childbearing, 2006-2010 National Survey of Family Growth,” from CDC’s National Center for Health Statistics, found that 8 in 10 teen males used a condom at first sex, an increase of 9 percentage points from 2002. The study also found that 16 percent of teen males used a condom in combination with a female partner’s hormonal method, a 6 percentage point increase from 2002.

Other findings include:
In 2006-2010, about 43 percent of never-married female teens (4.4 million), and about 42 percent of never-married male teens (4.5 million) had had sexual intercourse at least once (were sexually experienced). These levels of sexual experience have not changed significantly from 2002, though over the past 20 years there has been a decline in the percentages of those who were sexually experienced. Continue reading